cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

There should be seperate forum for ABAP HR

Former Member
0 Kudos

Hello folks,

I have recently joined SDN community. What I feel is that there should be different forum for ABAP HR. If I have to post a question or if I have to look what other members have asked in concern with ABAP HR then it is difficult to search in either ABAP or HCM forums.

Please suggest.

Accepted Solutions (0)

Answers (5)

Answers (5)

Former Member
0 Kudos

Hi Rahul,

I totally agree with you. It is really tough to extract ABAP HR related queries.

ThomasZloch
Active Contributor
0 Kudos

Moved to "suggestions and comments", please do not cross-post.

I think if there are enough voices here for this suggestion, there might be a chance. Only SCN admins can decide though. Sounds like functional issues should go to HCM, technical ABAP issues could go to a new ABAP HR sub-forum, now they usually appear in ABAP General.

Thomas

ChrisPaine
Active Contributor
0 Kudos

>technical ABAP issues could go to a new ABAP HR sub-forum

@Thomas - with much of the new HCM technology being delivered in WDA and associated techs (POWL, etc) many of the issues are cross application. Having another segregation would mean these questions getting lost or even more work for moderators to move posts across forums.

Tagging and being able to view all threads with a given tag (akin to the Google GMail labels for those needing a "real" example ) is the way to resolve these issues, but until we have a revolution in how SCN is organised, I'd be opposed to any further fragmentation. Perhaps I should set up an RSS reader and then going through multiple forums wouldn't be as tiresome, but I haven't got to that point, and I doubt most users have.

Just my thoughts!

Cheers,

Chris

ThomasZloch
Active Contributor
0 Kudos

You caught me, I don't have enough experience in HCM, ABAP HR or WDA to be able to really judge those problems in advance. In the areas I know better there is e.g. all the STMS stuff, a grey area between ABAP developer and system administrator, or the authorization objects, ABAP and/or security? Tagging would be much more flexible than fixed forum categories, I surely agree with that.

Thomas

Former Member
0 Kudos

Hello Guys,

Yeah I have posted it at three places. ABAP, HCM and Suggestions. I request other guys as well to post about this in suggestions and comments.

Thanks

MarcinPciak
Active Contributor
0 Kudos

>

> Hello Guys,

>

> Yeah I have posted it at three places. ABAP, HCM and Suggestions. I request other guys as well to post about this in suggestions and comments.

>

> Thanks

That's not too good unless you want to irritate Moderators;) I understand your motivation but by duplicating posts accross different forums you won't achieve too much.

Anyhow I don't think it is up to Moderators or any of us here. This kind of request should be directed to SCN Support Team . Of course the Moderators can support your idea but this is a technical change which I don't think is an obvious and straighforward thing.

Regards

Marcin

former_member209217
Active Contributor
0 Kudos

Hi Rahul,

Your query will be answered if you can put this in relevant forum [Suggestion and Comments|;

I too feel its good to have a separate forum,but it should be accepted by moderators first.

Regards,

Lakshman

MarcinPciak
Active Contributor
0 Kudos

Please post this suggestion in [Suggestions and Comments|; forum. Ask the moderator to move this thread there. For this click abuse button and write a request.

Regards

Marcin