Sales Return - COGS Value of PGR should be the same as PGI

[trisno_s]

Hello,

I'm a SD Consultant and I'm new to this forum.

Below is the document flow of our current sales return process:
Sales Order --> Delivery Order --> Post Goods Issue --> Billing --> Return Order --> Return
Delivery --> Post Goods Receipt
Return Order --> Credit Note

Credit Note has reference to Return Order, not to Return Delivery.

The requirement:
The managements have requested that COGS value posted from Post Goods Receipt and Credit Note should be the same as COGS value posted from Post Goods Issue and Billing.
Our companies are using Price Control = S for Distributors, and Price Control = V for
Factories. Both Factories and Distributors can sell, but each has their own different customers.
The managements have already aware about its effect to costing, and they've accepted it.

Example:
In September, COGS value of item A is 10$. From Accounting Document of Goods Issue material document, we can see the COGS of item A is 10$.
In October, COGS value of item A is 11$. If the Billing from September is used as Return Order reference, and the Return Order is processed until Credit Note, we want to use 10$ as COGS value posted from Post Goods Receipt and Credit Note - whereas the standard process will take 11$.

The idea is to put a code in an User Exit triggered when User clicked "Post Goods Issue" button in tcode VL02N or VL06G. This code will fetch COGS value (VPRS) per line item from Billing that has been used as Return Order reference and overrides the original COGS value when the Accounting Document of Goods Receipt material document is made.
Some has mentioned to use BADI LE_SHP_GOODSMOVEMENT, but we can't find it, for we're still using SAP 4.6c version.

I've read several threads I found below - but none mention definite answer.
https://archive.sap.com/discussions/thread/3489972
https://archive.sap.com/discussions/thread/3307720
https://archive.sap.com/discussions/thread/3343155
https://archive.sap.com/discussions/thread/3306800
https://archive.sap.com/discussions/thread/1428245

The question:
Is there any User Exit we can use when User clicked "Post Goods Issue" button in tcode VL02N or VL06G in SAP 4.6C version? Or, if there's other idea, I'm open to suggestion.


Thank you and regards,


Trisno S.

[former_member767867]

Can any one has the answer for it, I have same issue. What should I do if I want PGR should be same as PGI for a particular condition ( like for a only one company code) ?

[former_member751591]

Thanks for coming to SAP Community for answers. Please post your question as a new question here:

Since you're new in asking questions here, check out our tutorial about asking and answering questions (if you haven't already), as it provides tips for preparing questions more effectively, that draw responses from our members.

Please note, that your post here won't be answered.

[trisno_s]

Hello,

I've been searching for weeks and still haven't found any solution. I start to believe that it is impossible to achieve my goal.

Therefore, is there any insights or ways to convince the users that the goal is impossible to be achieved except for reason that system is unable to do so?

Thank you.

[veenadhari_thottempudi]

Hi,

Can you please share your solution please. i am having similar issue and been looking for the solution since one week. Thank you!

[former_member786627]

hi Trisno,

We are looking for a similar solution to update the COGS during PGR into a special scenario plant.
Did you get a response or any possible user exit/Badi to achieve this?
Any inputs will help
thank you !

Best regards,
Shailaja

[trisno_s]

Hello, anyone?

[trisno_s]

Hello,

Anyone?

If you have experience regarding this, whether you did it by providing user exits or convincing the users to change, please kindly share your insight or solution.

Thanks and regards,

Trisno S.

[trisno_s]

Hello Sir,

I've been reading the OSS Note, but it's not what I'm looking for.

I'm not trying to recalculate VPRS in existing Billing. The existing transactions will be left as they are. I'm talking about new transactions, so that the value of BSEG-WRBTR can be changed automatically using user exit or enhancements when Users doing Post Goods Receipt.

I noticed that this thread below has some success regarding MSEG-DMBTR but not BSEG-WRBTR:

https://archive.sap.com/discussions/thread/3958368

Kindly need anyone's input.

Thanks and regards,

Trisno S.

[Lakshmipathi]

Take the inputs from OSS note 1933844. Else, try with program SDVPRSUPDATE

[trisno_s]

I don't see any button to edit my initial post, so I'm going with new post to clarify my requirements.

My requirement is to change BSEG-WRBTR field of COGS value in Accounting Document created by GR Material Document when we're doing Post Goods Receipt through tcode VL02N.

Basically, the flow is as follow:

1. User creates Return Order with reference to Billing with VA01
2. User creates Return Delivery with VL01N
3. User process Return Delivery with VL02N by clicking Post Goods Issue button
4. GR Material Document created
5. Accounting Document created (before Accounting Document is created, we want to change BSEG-WRBTR based on VRPS in Billing that has been used as reference for related Return Order, instead of using its original value)

I've found almost similar thread like mine below - but it doesn't have an answer:

https://archive.sap.com/discussions/thread/3656307

BADI LE_SHP_GOODSMOVEMENT and AC_DOCUMENT aren't found in my current SAP (4.6c). As for BTE, I don't have any idea about it.

Kindly need your help.

Thanks and regards,

Trisno S.

[trisno_s]

Hello Sir,

Thanks for replying.

If I'm not mistaken, RV60AFZZ is for Billing, while my requirement is to use user exit when Post Goods Issue button is clicked, before any Credit Note is made, therefore, changing COGS value in Accounting Document of GR material document. Can you tell me their relation or explain further?

I've seen my current RV60AFZZ, but it doesn't have form USEREXIT_VPRS_UPDATE.

Thanks and regards,

Trisno S.

[trisno_s]

Hello Sir,

This is the second time I write this post, I don't see where my first post anywhere.

User Exit RV60AFZZ is for Billing. I'm not sure if it's related to COGS value in Accounting Document of GR Material Document. Does RV60AFZZ get executed when we clicked Post Goods Issue button?
Also, I don't see USEREXIT_VPRS_UPDATE in my own RV60AFZZ. Can you please elaborate about it?

Thank you and regards,


Trisno S.

[Lakshmipathi]

First of all, good that you made some attempts to search before posting here and also for explaining your requirement clearly. Now coming to your requirement, you can include the form routine USEREXIT_VPRS_UPDATE in include RV60AFZZ and add your own logic