sync RFC scenario VS BPM scenario -- speed doubt

[Former Member]

Hello friends!

My case:

I have to choose between 2 scenarios:

1) SAP(Idoc) <=> XI <=> ThirdPart(WebService)

2) SAP(s\q\tRFC) <=> XI <=> ThirdPart(WebService)

In 1st scenario I need to use BPM. In 2sd I needn't.

So I want to know which way more simple to implement and more speedy.

Thanks in advance!

Alexandr

[Former Member · Accepted solution]

Hello

As according to your choice the second option is more optimized way

i.e. SAP(s\q\tRFC) <=> XI <=> ThirdPart(WebService)

this is because of various instances which get started such as mesage instance or other instances so that would not be optimized or speedy as of your first option .

Thank's

Chetan Ahuja

[Former Member]

Hi,

Performence wise SAP(RFC)--XI---SOAP is the Better way

Regards

Seshagiri

[Former Member]

Second one is better in terms of both performance, testing and monitoring. Monitoring of BPM is not all that easy.

Thanks,

Valli

[prateek]

Second approach would be better in terms of performance. The development time for both the approach would be almost same but however, the development would be easier in approach 2.

Regards,

Prateek

[Former Member]

Hi,

BPM is more productive........

Thanks,

Madhu

[Former Member]

hi

The first case is easier i.e with BPM...in terms of hadling errors..to send any alerts.....

if you want any weblogs i can post for you

regards

kummari