Skip to Content
avatar image
Former Member

Product Costing without use secondary cost element

Hi Experts,

I have a client with this request:

1. They have SAP system with PP, PM, SD, MM, FI, CO, Material Ledger modules.

2. They use maintenance orders, production orders, cost centers.

3. To carry on cost from cost object to other they use settlement, assessment, revaluate rates, with secondary cost elements.

4. REQUEST: They need to report the production cost with primary cost element only.

They tried with abap program without good results.

Now they want to try using Distribution method and Settlement with the same primary cost elements.

Step 1: From "Maintenance Labor cost center" to "PM Orders" using Distribution.

Step 2: From "PM Orders" to "User Cost Center", using Settlement with primary cost elements.

Step 3: From "Indirect cost center" to "Direct cost center" using Distribution.

Step 4: From "Direct Cost Center" to "Production Orders" using Distribution.

I would like to know your opinions. Is it feasible?

Thanks in advance for your help.

Regards,

PEP

Add comment
10|10000 characters needed characters exceeded

  • Get RSS Feed

3 Answers

  • Best Answer
    Oct 31, 2017 at 05:14 AM

    Hi Pep,

    My opinion is below:

    Step 1: From "Maintenance Labor cost center" to "PM Orders" using Distribution. --> Technically feasible,

    Step 2: From "PM Orders" to "User Cost Center", using Settlement with primary cost elements--> Technically feasible, you have to run program "

    RKALPSAC" so order will become valid sender object

    Step 3: From "Indirect cost center" to "Direct cost center" using Distribution.--> Feasible

    Step 4: From "Direct Cost Center" to "Production Orders" using Distribution.--> Not possible system will not allow to transfer cost from cost center to production order through dist / allocation cycle

    Regards,
    Malay

    Add comment
    10|10000 characters needed characters exceeded

  • Oct 05, 2017 at 06:59 AM

    Strange requirement I never heard about something until now but I would use a Primary cost Component structures as an

    auxiliary structure and assure that all my activity type rates are planned with a cost Component structured (Primary cost componet) which is automatically rolled up in the product costing.

    Step 1: direct activity allocation with rates and Component structure

    Step 2: agree -> settlement with origin cost elements

    Step 3: agree but you could use indirect activity allocation too if you maintain a cost Component structure in your co version (same as step 1)

    Step 4: see Step 1

    Add comment
    10|10000 characters needed characters exceeded

    • activity prices with cost component structures can be used through the whole controlling if you add one to your co version. the fi/co part of PM orders is the same

      But your assumption is correct ... the transfer from pm order to the cost center is not able to use the cost Component structure anymore.

      Hmm ... that was my first and only idea ...

      As Muhammad already said you can not use PM orders in Distribution cycles but you can use internal orders and then do a settlement on a origin cost element base.

      But if this is a legal requirement in your Country I am you browse your local SAP consultancies maybe there exists already a 3rd Party solution.

      lgh7r.png (138.6 kB)
  • Oct 07, 2017 at 08:36 PM

    i dont know why your company require this but as per my understanding solution is as under:-

    Step 1: From "Maintenance Labor cost center" to "PM Orders" using Distribution.

    as far as i know you cannot use PM order in distribution cycle. how ever through direct activity allocation KB21N you can post cost on PM orders.

    Step 2: From "PM Orders" to "User Cost Center", using Settlement with primary cost elements.

    it is possible to use primary cost elements with the help of source structure and allocation structure

    Step 3: From "Indirect cost center" to "Direct cost center" using Distribution.

    distribution cycle is used to allocate primary cost only.

    Step 4: From "Direct Cost Center" to "Production Orders" using Distribution.

    not possible. system will not allow you to allocate cost. infect you cannot create distribution cycle while using Production order as receiver objects

    Add comment
    10|10000 characters needed characters exceeded

    • thats great. i know with BS12 you can activate it but am confused about standard cost estimate with activities. and PP confirmation.What would be your PP confirmation step? will it be without activities? how will you calculate standard cost estimate if you are not using activities.