Idoc Vs Proxy

[Former Member]

Hi Experts,

I have a scenario like i want to transfer the Idoc data from One sap system to another sap system through XI. So What is the best option to do this useing IDoc or Proxy?

Can you please breiefly explain me above Adavantage & Disadvanctage of these ways and Which one is best for me in this scenario.

Thanks in Advance,

Points rewared for each valuable answers.

Best Regards,

Vijay

[justin_santhanam · Accepted solution]

Vijay,

I would suggest you to go for IDOC-to-IDOC . Please refer the below weblog.

/people/michal.krawczyk2/blog/2005/11/21/xi-idoc-to-idoc-tunneling--how-fast-and-easy-can-you-get

The reason behind this is, there is concept of IDOC -Tunneling.If my understanding is not wrong ,there is no XML trnasformations happens in this case. XI just acts as tunnnel btw those to systems.

Best regards,

raj.

[Former Member]

I would for IDOC if i have an IDOC and the scenario is asychorouse.

IDOC advt:

Error handling

Montoring

resend

debugging

no need of custom coding

regards

sreeram.g.reddy

[agasthuri_doss]

Hi,

It all depends upon the business Scenerio..

Proxies can be used when data is huge and it is quite fast in action and you can trigger when ever you want...

Assume if the data has to be updated immediately to the receiver system in that case IDOC is fine...once the Idoc is created we can trigger it by settings or thru by back ground job and by Tcode we02 we can find the status of the IDOC

Regards

Agasthuri Doss