Only one product promotion from non exclusive group is executed

[former_member683174]

Hi,

I published two product percentage discount promotions on the same product. They are both part of productPromotionRuleGroup which has Exclusivity flag set to false. When I calculate cart which meets the conditions of both promotions, only one promotion is fired.

I'm using Hybris 1808

Is this a bug? Or if not how can I change behaviour of promotions so both get fired.

First promotion: action

 [{"definitionId":"y_order_entry_fixed_discount","parameters":{"value":{"uuid":"1d8bf69f-f897-4d3b-bed9-70ab11c3b6b9","type":"Map(ItemType(Currency),java.math.BigDecimal)","value":{"USD":1}}}}]

condition

 [{"definitionId":"y_group","parameters":{"operator":{"uuid":"0fdc6312-aa55-46c1-9c44-c2e9589f69a2","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruleengineservices.definitions.conditions.RuleGroupOperator)","value":"OR"}},"children":[{"definitionId":"y_qualifying_products","parameters":{"catalog_version":{"uuid":"4c9f84ff-aa66-4db9-ba6d-1e95ac49cc12","type":"ItemType(CatalogVersion)"},"products_operator":{"uuid":"ff07643a-659e-4d0c-8e43-05bcb83dd018","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.CollectionOperator)","value":"CONTAINS_ANY"},"quantity":{"uuid":"430c2963-51c5-408c-9b13-b36d29d9c436","type":"java.lang.Integer","value":1},"total_quantity":{"uuid":"abc294fa-3c10-40b1-8b00-867647aff9f8","type":"java.lang.Boolean","value":false},"excluded_products":{"uuid":"756f9d7c-a30e-4311-a430-88f4ae8e2c5d","type":"List(ItemType(Product))"},"operator":{"uuid":"581f98cc-ab45-48fd-a7b3-7c7367cec248","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.AmountOperator)","value":"GREATER_THAN_OR_EQUAL"},"products":{"uuid":"b78e8cb3-c6d8-41c5-a312-8d717e3c3b5a","type":"List(ItemType(Product))","value":["1234"]}},"children":[]},{"definitionId":"y_qualifying_collections","parameters":{"quantity":{"uuid":"bc93d60e-d6ce-474b-837b-899b6e182821","type":"java.lang.Integer","value":1},"collections":{"uuid":"b3cbc1bd-b1f6-4e6e-90a5-b9889ff274a0","type":"List(ItemType(CommerceCollection))"},"collections_operator":{"uuid":"42f366c7-5bfe-47a9-94de-0ea9f26bc8b1","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.CollectionOperator)","value":"CONTAINS_ANY"},"total_quantity":{"uuid":"1ac91606-6696-428e-8105-a5003cfe51b9","type":"java.lang.Boolean","value":false},"excluded_products":{"uuid":"c131dedb-add8-4f79-ac5c-d48e484e43b0","type":"List(ItemType(Product))"},"operator":{"uuid":"d274ae70-d69b-4d17-91a4-f171b228e492","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.AmountOperator)","value":"GREATER_THAN_OR_EQUAL"}},"children":[]},{"definitionId":"y_qualifying_categories","parameters":{"quantity":{"uuid":"1d21ebc3-865e-4575-b394-002f242fff4d","type":"java.lang.Integer","value":1},"categories_operator":{"uuid":"d6413ba4-d607-462e-b115-93ee3b6a4950","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.CollectionOperator)","value":"CONTAINS_ANY"},"total_quantity":{"uuid":"fca637aa-4e16-4d08-8e94-f608776a3d0d","type":"java.lang.Boolean","value":false},"excluded_categories":{"uuid":"e8348cfa-c314-4afc-8859-c3fd05f36bb4","type":"List(ItemType(Category))"},"categories":{"uuid":"f2e87e37-c043-46a2-a89e-b2a94f5b7b1f","type":"List(ItemType(Category))","value":[]},"excluded_products":{"uuid":"33faf84d-f2dc-4e05-bf00-574006e95c49","type":"List(ItemType(Product))","value":[]},"operator":{"uuid":"3a3ee87b-82cf-470f-b063-29b2f84ec83e","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.AmountOperator)","value":"GREATER_THAN_OR_EQUAL"}},"children":[]}]},{"definitionId":"base_store","parameters":{},"children":[]}]

second promotion: action

 [{"definitionId":"y_order_entry_percentage_discount","parameters":{"value":{"uuid":"a1a5d598-c351-43a4-92bf-eb63d877496a","type":"java.math.BigDecimal","value":10}}}]

condition

 [{"definitionId":"y_group","parameters":{"operator":{"uuid":"0bc4e42c-3b09-426c-a964-d5e7a296c498","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruleengineservices.definitions.conditions.RuleGroupOperator)","value":"OR"}},"children":[{"definitionId":"y_qualifying_products","parameters":{"catalog_version":{"uuid":"b51b75eb-5557-4a4d-a9e5-f0eb8094d6b1","type":"ItemType(CatalogVersion)"},"products_operator":{"uuid":"d6255410-0de6-4064-ae3e-5de2491b1b73","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.CollectionOperator)","value":"CONTAINS_ANY"},"quantity":{"uuid":"bac61470-129f-4d91-b725-d2019c71257b","type":"java.lang.Integer","value":1},"total_quantity":{"uuid":"40853de6-2284-423c-b08d-932c23126598","type":"java.lang.Boolean","value":false},"excluded_products":{"uuid":"dfe3b53e-6bf3-4dd6-abb3-8d6f68754c5b","type":"List(ItemType(Product))"},"operator":{"uuid":"a2f05b73-068d-45c2-bc28-ea163c3a893c","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.AmountOperator)","value":"GREATER_THAN_OR_EQUAL"},"products":{"uuid":"df622983-baac-4356-a4b9-fb6ea466fbc4","type":"List(ItemType(Product))","value":["1234"]}},"children":[]},{"definitionId":"y_qualifying_collections","parameters":{"quantity":{"uuid":"1c0cc070-34ea-44de-9337-23fa855a264d","type":"java.lang.Integer","value":1},"collections":{"uuid":"07210a98-6203-4621-a645-56e69b60423e","type":"List(ItemType(CommerceCollection))","value":[]},"collections_operator":{"uuid":"5e03ed03-4302-4ba2-903c-febeb584ee71","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.CollectionOperator)","value":"CONTAINS_ANY"},"total_quantity":{"uuid":"052cf6d5-2379-4853-a41a-130805591207","type":"java.lang.Boolean","value":false},"excluded_products":{"uuid":"9324d613-fb20-4536-bf54-225874bfbde2","type":"List(ItemType(Product))","value":[]},"operator":{"uuid":"0bc6eb0e-c39b-4679-af54-9ce624bf92a2","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.AmountOperator)","value":"GREATER_THAN_OR_EQUAL"}},"children":[]},{"definitionId":"y_qualifying_categories","parameters":{"quantity":{"uuid":"6307770f-e851-45a3-bc73-88634f8a4443","type":"java.lang.Integer","value":1},"categories_operator":{"uuid":"c361f681-2f88-44c4-acf5-27281568e313","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.CollectionOperator)","value":"CONTAINS_ANY"},"total_quantity":{"uuid":"722c9a50-21fa-4a7f-940b-2578aec5b7ea","type":"java.lang.Boolean","value":false},"excluded_categories":{"uuid":"dd0f76d2-f8be-4dc0-a68a-b94c2259327b","type":"List(ItemType(Category))","value":[]},"categories":{"uuid":"83e6ca48-3441-49e2-b3ff-eabb479e9966","type":"List(ItemType(Category))","value":[]},"excluded_products":{"uuid":"047bea52-4d89-4c97-8994-442239fc456c","type":"List(ItemType(Product))","value":[]},"operator":{"uuid":"631c6ced-468c-46c8-b4ca-97a3a3ac10b8","type":"Enum(de.hybris.platform.ruledefinitions.AmountOperator)","value":"GREATER_THAN_OR_EQUAL"}},"children":[]}]},{"definitionId":"base_store","parameters":{},"children":[]}]

Thanks in advance, Josip

[geffchang]

Have you republished the modules?

[former_member683174]

Hi Geff, tnx for your advice. Unfortunately I tried it and it didn't help.

[former_member1044980]

A non-exclusive rule group called "Product Discounts" contains all promotion rules that apply to specific products. You make this rule group non-exclusive because you want customers to be able to enjoy discounts on multiple products in the same cart. (You do not need to worry about multiple promotion rules discounting the same product: Promotion Engine ensures that the same product is never discounted twice. For more information, see Order Entry Consumption.)

https://help.sap.com/viewer/9d346683b0084da2938be8a285c0c27a/2011/en-US/e167d5d0f1604ce6ad300fd7c4f5...

[rudolf_castelino]

can u add the promotion definition to the question? i tried this on 1808, electronics accelerator and had no problems. both promotions were applied

[former_member683174]

sure, added

[rudolf_castelino]

have u checked the promotion priority? if u have the same priority on both the promotions, then onlyu one will get applied

[former_member683174]

Yes, tried with both promotions having priority 0 and one having 1000 and one 0

[former_member1320010]

is stackable flag true for both promotions ? (assuming you are using the new promotion engine - with drools)

[former_member683174]

I tried with stackable true/false/null on both promotions and it's always the same result.

[former_member683174]

I tested on 6.6 and both promotions get executed. Anyone know if this is a bug and will it be fixed in future releases? Or is there some workaround?