Skip to Content

SAP Community and the Migrated SCN Content

0

I have a question/opinion on the migration rules of old SCN content to the new SAP Community platform - SAP has chosen to migrate only the SCN discussions with replies, it is a good strategy to clean-up the unwanted content.

I have comes across multiple SCN discussions that were not migrated as no one replied to them but the links to these discussions were referred to in several other discussions.

I believe SAP should consider expanding the rules to include such content, especially when the link is mentioned in the context of an Helpful Answer or Correct Answer.

Dear Community Members, What is your take on this?

coffercorner.jpg (156.4 kB)
0
Show 12
* Please Login or Register to Comment on or Follow discussions.
avatar image
6 days ago
155

Why should several answers to other discussions point to a question without answer? This does not make much sense to me.

It would be good if you could post a link to such a question which has a link to a non-migrated question as correct answer to enable us and the technical guys behind the scenes to investigate on that matter.

0 Share
Jürgen, thanks for your response. Here is the link to a question which has responses with dead links.

https://archive.sap.com/discussions/thread/133057

0 Share

It's just a bunch of "link farm" posts back from 2007 when the moderators could not remove them fast enough.

People would just go to Google, search for what OP should've searched and then blindly copy-paste the links hoping that OP "award if useful". Typical point-hunting behavior.

There is no reason to migrate unanswered questions no matter whether they're linked anywhere or not.

1 Share
Jelena Perfiljeva
4 days ago

It makes total sense on why you should migrate unanswered discussions in theory. Might be SAP can monitor for a month to see how many hits are coming to these links and take a decision if they need to be migrated.

There should be some reason the OP chose the reply with posts as a Helpful Answer over other Answers.

0 Share

Adding @brian.ellefritz to the conversation.

0 Share

What "total" sense "in theory" does it make specifically? You have not mentioned a single valid reason so far. How do you expect your point of view to be taken seriously?

Either way they are already gone, I'm afraid, so this is really a moot point IMHO. The plans were announced on SCN months ago, should've spoken out back then if it was important.

By the way, @-mention no longer works either. Bummer!

0 Share
Jelena Perfiljeva
3 days ago

Jelena, I gave you a real example where I am unable to access a helpful answer do I don't know what else I can give. To find out if other users are facing this problem, I have asked if SAP can turn on a trace to see how many hits are coming to the deadlinks.

Thank you for taking time to respond to my question.

0 Share
Show more comments
Jelena Perfiljeva
3 days ago

The problem is when you can see a preview on internet archive of the answers and then, when you try to open, you got the message (true story, sis!)

1 Share

There is a preview?! I feel like I've accidentally stumbled into some kind of parallel universe...

0 Share
Jelena Perfiljeva
3 days ago

Sorry, preview maybe is the wrong term,

here an example about what i mean (this one is an example, i took from the 1st link i found).

You see 6 replies in Google cache, but, sometimes, the real/actual archive is not reachable

snapshot.png (51.5 kB)
1 Share
10 |10000 characters needed characters left characters exceeded